AmmoSight

Dispatch / 11.17.26· Law & Courts ·Second Circuit

Second Circuit Revives Challenge to New York City's One-Handgun Carry Limit and 90-Day Purchase Rule

The Nov. 10 opinion in Mills v. New York City holds that both rules restrict conduct the Second Amendment's text covers, sends them back to Judge Rakoff for a historical analysis the city must win, and leaves the $340 license fee upheld under Kwong.

By Published
Credit: Photo: TJ Bickerton, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Key Facts

  • The Second Circuit vacated part of the Dec. 5, 2024 Mills v. New York City dismissal on Nov. 10, 2026.
  • New York City limits carry licensees to one handgun on the person and one handgun purchase every 90 days.
  • The panel held the Second Amendment's plural 'Arms' places no numerical limit on carry at Bruen step one.
  • The $340 license fee, charged since 2004, stays upheld under the court's 2013 Kwong v. Bloomberg decision.
  • The city repealed its two-handgun carry-license cap on Aug. 12, 2024, leaving only Mills's damages claim.

On November 10, 2026, the Second Circuit revived a Second Amendment challenge to two New York City handgun rules, the limit of one handgun carried on the person at a time and the 90-day wait between handgun purchases, holding that a federal judge dismissed those claims prematurely. The three-judge panel’s 40-page opinion in Mills v. New York City, No. 24-3308, vacates part of Judge Jed S. Rakoff’s December 5, 2024 judgment and returns the case to the Southern District of New York, where the city must now show that the rules fit the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.

Both rules stay in force for now. Judge Reena Raggi, writing for a panel with Judges Debra Ann Livingston and Michael H. Park, said the ruling does not mean the rules “are necessarily unconstitutional.” It holds only that their constitutionality must be decided at the second step of the test the Supreme Court set out in 2022 in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, the step at which the government carries the burden.

Three plaintiffs filed the suit on August 23, 2022. Charles Mills of Queens holds a premises license and a carry license. He says he would routinely carry a second, back-up handgun and would have bought a Glock from a Queens gun shop but for the 90-day limit. Craig Sotomayor of Nassau County holds a state carry license and the city’s special license for nonresidents. Braden Holliday of the Bronx says he cannot afford the $340 application fee, the $88.50 fingerprinting fee or the $340 renewal that comes due every third year.

Rakoff dismissed the complaint in full. He found that no plaintiff had standing to attack the purchase-authorization and registration rules, and he held that the one-gun carry rule, the 90-day rule, a since-repealed two-gun cap on carry licenses and the fees did not regulate conduct covered by the Second Amendment’s plain text, so those claims failed at Bruen’s first step.

The panel found two general errors in that reasoning. Nothing in the amendment’s text, Raggi wrote, draws a line between temporary and permanent deprivations, and founding-era dictionaries defined “infringe” to reach hindering a right as well as destroying it. A plaintiff opposing a motion to dismiss also has no duty to show that a rule is “foreclosed by the text of the Second Amendment.” At step one, the plaintiff need only plausibly allege that the rule places some restriction on keeping or bearing arms. The court said the Supreme Court’s 2026 Wolford v. Lopez decision now supplies the step-one questions and declined to follow the Fourth Circuit’s contrary en banc Maryland Shall Issue approach.

On the carry limit, 38 R.C.N.Y. § 5-22(a)(7), the court held that the right to “bear Arms” is stated in the plural and “does not place a numerical limit on this right,” citing the Ninth Circuit’s Nguyen v. Bonta and the D.C. Circuit’s 2015 Heller decision. The city argued that founding-era small arms were single-shot weapons that had to be reloaded by hand after every shot, so nobody then contemplated carrying several. The panel answered that the need to reload might have made carrying several guns more likely, and that the point belongs at step two in any event.

On the 90-day rule, N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 10-302.1, the court distinguished the short delays of licensing paperwork it has upheld in Gazzola v. Hochul and Frey v. City of New York. The city conceded that the rule’s purpose is to slow “the pace of additional firearm acquisitions” and to deter straw buyers. “Perhaps so,” Raggi wrote, but a rule whose purpose is delay meaningfully constrains the right at step one, as the Ninth Circuit held of California’s one-handgun-in-30-days law. A footnote leaves open how the court would view a 72-hour waiting period of the kind the First Circuit upheld this year in Beckwith v. Frey.

The panel also revived Mills’s damages claim over the city’s former cap of two handguns registered to a carry license, 38 R.C.N.Y. § 5-25(d)(4). The city repealed that cap on August 12, 2024, and its new rule no longer sets a strict limit, so only the claim for past damages remains. Because state law makes carrying a handgun not registered to a carry license a Class A misdemeanor, the cap “effectively prevented Mills from carrying all but two of his lawfully owned handguns,” the court said.

The fee claims stay dismissed. The court’s 2013 decision in Kwong v. Bloomberg upheld the same $340 fee, which has stood since 2004 and has not risen since Kwong. Outside the city, Nassau County and Westchester County, New York caps handgun license fees at $10. Holliday’s claim that he could not afford the fee was pleaded without any facts about his finances. Challenges to the purchase-authorization rule, the registration rule and the dealer-reporting requirements were correctly dismissed for lack of standing, the panel said, because no plaintiff alleged an injury that those rules themselves caused.

Amy L. Bellantoni of Scarsdale argued for the plaintiffs. Assistant Corporation Counsel Jeremy W. Shweder argued for the city. Everytown for Gun Safety backed the city as amicus, and Paul D. Clement’s firm backed the plaintiffs for the National Shooting Sports Foundation. Rakoff had written that the revived claims would “likely fail” at step two. The panel called that remark “more suggestive than conclusory” and said it expects a particularized historical analysis on remand. The claims return to Rakoff’s court in Manhattan with no schedule set as of November 17, 2026.

Sources

  1. 1 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Mills v. New York City, No. 24-3308-cv (2d Cir. Nov. 10, 2026), opinion · accessed 2026-11-18
  2. 2 CourtListener · Mills v. New York City, CourtListener opinion page · accessed 2026-11-18
  3. 3 Supreme Court of the United States · New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, No. 20-843 (U.S. June 23, 2022), opinion · accessed 2026-11-18

For brands and PR

Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.

Contact the newsroom

Related Stories