Dispatch / 11.18.26· Law & Courts
Retired ATF Tracing Chief Backs 20-Year Dealer Limit and GOA Demands Deletion of 1.41 Billion Closed-Dealer Records at House Oversight Hearing
Written testimony for the Nov. 18 Federal Law Enforcement subcommittee hearing puts ATF's intake at 8 million records a month with 120 million pages unimaged. Nelson says there is no registry at the tracing center. Gun Owners of America says there is.

Key Facts
- The Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement heard four witnesses on Nov. 18, 2026 at 2 p.m. in Rayburn 2154.
- Walfred Nelson, who ran the tracing center from 1998 to 2005, backs 20 years for dealers and 30 for ATF.
- Gun Owners of America puts the archive at 1,414,088,513 records as of May 19, 2026 and asks for deletion.
- ATF received 8 million out-of-business records a month in 2026 and holds about 120 million unimaged pages.
- Gregory Jackson says 52 percent of trace requests from 2000 to 2023 used out-of-business records.
The retired ATF official who ran the National Tracing Center for seven years told a House Oversight subcommittee that the bureau should keep closed dealers’ records for 30 years and dealers for 20, while Gun Owners of America asked Congress to have ATF delete an archive it puts at 1,414,088,513 records, in written testimony posted for the Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement’s hearing on Nov. 18, 2026 at 2 p.m. in Rayburn 2154.
The subcommittee, chaired by Rep. Clay Higgins with Rep. Greg Casar as ranking member, listed four witnesses: Walfred A. Nelson, a retired ATF deputy assistant director and compliance consultant, Aidan Johnston, Gun Owners of America’s director of federal affairs, Christopher Chiafullo, founder and national coordinating counsel of FFLGuard, and Gregory Jackson, a former deputy director of the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention, as the minority witness.
Nelson supervised the tracing center from January 1998 until he retired in 2005. In his statement he backs ATF’s May 6 proposed rule to end indefinite retention of dealers’ acquisition and disposition books and Form 4473s, the transaction record a buyer fills out for a background check, and return to the 20-year period that stood from 1985 until a 2022 rule made retention permanent. He cites the rule’s own figures: of 528,058 traces in fiscal 2021, 0.26 percent, or 1,349, were closed because a dealer had destroyed records older than 20 years, 89 percent of traces in 2026 involved records under 20 years old, 87 percent of traced guns were recovered within 20 years of sale, and out-of-business records supported 25 percent of traces in 2015 but 11 percent in 2024. For ATF’s own holdings, which he estimates at 1.3 billion records, he recommends a 30-year limit from receipt so the bureau can trace a gun for up to 50 years after its sale, a span he says covers 94 percent of traces.
Nelson also describes the backlog. ATF received an average of 6.5 million out-of-business records a month in 2025 and 8 million a month in 2026, he writes, and holds about 50,000 large boxes, roughly 120 million pages, in a warehouse awaiting imaging, along with more than 50,000 reels of microfilm from 1991 to 2005. The imaged records can be searched only by the submitting dealer’s identity, and for electronic files by serial number. “I know that there is no firearm registry at the NTC,” he writes, and destroying the older records “should improve” trace processing.
Johnston’s 111-page report, filed as his testimony, opens with the sentence “There is a national gun registry.” It says ATF told Rep. Michael Cloud in a June 10, 2026 letter that it held 1,414,088,513 out-of-business records as of May 19, up from 920,664,765 in November 2021, of which 865,787,086 were digitized. GOA urges the administration “to delete all unlawful registration records and to cease collecting and digitizing gun records immediately” and rejects the proposed rule because, by its reading, a dealer’s 30 years and ATF’s 30 years can stack to 60. The report recounts the House Appropriations Committee’s 29-to-25 vote on July 9, 2024 for a Clyde amendment barring ATF from using funds to record or maintain the records.
Chiafullo’s statement for FFLGuard, which represents licensed dealers, supports the pending rule as “a meaningful regulatory development” and notes that NSSF’s July 30, 2026 comment also backs a 20-year period. He writes that ATF’s data show most successful traces identifying a purchaser involve records under 20 years old, and that whether ATF may digitize and keep surrendered records at all is a threshold legal question the hearing should take up.
Jackson’s statement defends the archive. It says 52 percent of crime-gun trace requests from 2000 to 2023 were completed using out-of-business records, more than 4.6 million traces or an average of over 520 a day, and that ATF reported prosecuting an average of 8,310 cases a year from 2016 to 2020 involving a firearm more than 20 years old. He quotes ATF Director Robert Cekada’s statement that “ATF does not have an illegal firearm registry.”
The proposed rule, RIN 1140-AA95, would set a 20- or 30-year period for dealer records and for records the tracing center receives, five years for Form 4473s with no transfer and 90 days for private-party and firearms-handler checks. Its comment period closed Aug. 4, and ATF had published no final rule as of Nov. 18.
Sources
- 1 House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform · Oversight of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives' Out-of-Business Records Retention Practices · accessed 2026-11-18
- 2 House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform · Statement of Walfred A. Nelson · accessed 2026-11-18
- 3 House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform · ATF's Illegal Gun Owner Registry (written testimony of Aidan Johnston) · accessed 2026-11-18
- 4 House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform · Written Testimony of Christopher Chiafullo · accessed 2026-11-18
- 5 House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform · Testimony of Gregory Jackson, Jr. · accessed 2026-11-18
- 6 Federal Register · Firearm Records Retention Periods · accessed 2026-11-18
For brands and PR
Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.
Contact the newsroomRelated Stories
Law & Courts · Nov 18
Federal Judge Dismisses Justice Department Suit Against Montgomery County's 100-Yard Gun-Free Zones, Rejecting the Pattern-or-Practice Theory
Judge Theodore D. Chuang ruled Nov. 9 that 34 U.S.C. § 12601, the 1994 police pattern-or-practice statute, does not let the department challenge a county firearms ordinance, and denied its injunction without reaching the Second Amendment.
Law & Courts · Nov 17
Second Circuit Revives Challenge to New York City's One-Handgun Carry Limit and 90-Day Purchase Rule
The Nov. 10 opinion in Mills v. New York City holds that both rules restrict conduct the Second Amendment's text covers, sends them back to Judge Rakoff for a historical analysis the city must win, and leaves the $340 license fee upheld under Kwong.
Law & Courts · Nov 17
Winchester, Virginia, Paid $37,172.78 Defending a Parking Garage Gun Ban It Then Repealed, FOIA Records Show
Seven checks to the city's defense firm total $35,862.78 and a city attorney invoice adds $1,310. The city says it has no records of the defense firm's hourly rate, and the case was dismissed as moot in May 2026 after the council exempted its garages.