AmmoSight

Dispatch / 11.18.26· Law & Courts

Federal Judge Dismisses Justice Department Suit Against Montgomery County's 100-Yard Gun-Free Zones, Rejecting the Pattern-or-Practice Theory

Judge Theodore D. Chuang ruled Nov. 9 that 34 U.S.C. § 12601, the 1994 police pattern-or-practice statute, does not let the department challenge a county firearms ordinance, and denied its injunction without reaching the Second Amendment.

By Published
Credit: Photo: Acroterion, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Key Facts

  • Judge Theodore D. Chuang dismissed United States v. Montgomery County, No. 26-3025-TDC, on Nov. 9, 2026.
  • The department sued Aug. 3, 2026 under 34 U.S.C. § 12601, a week after Bill 23-26 passed July 27.
  • Bill 23-26 bars firearms and ammunition within 100 yards of ten kinds of public assembly places.
  • The court found no pattern or practice by officers and called the suit a facial challenge to the ordinance.
  • The motion for a preliminary injunction was denied, and the Second Amendment merits were not reached.

A federal judge dismissed the Justice Department’s lawsuit against Montgomery County, Maryland, over its ban on firearms within 100 yards of parks, schools, places of worship and other places of public assembly, ruling in a memorandum opinion filed Nov. 9, 2026 that the civil rights statute the department invoked does not reach a county gun law.

U.S. District Judge Theodore D. Chuang granted the county’s motion to dismiss and denied the department’s motion for a preliminary injunction without reaching the Second Amendment question. The department sued under 34 U.S.C. § 12601, a 1994 statute that lets the attorney general seek an injunction against a pattern or practice of conduct by law enforcement officers that deprives people of constitutional rights. Chuang found the complaint alleged no such pattern. Its claim, he wrote, “is essentially a facial challenge to the constitutionality” of the county ordinance, and the statute “cannot properly be construed in a manner that provides the sweeping authority contemplated by the Government.”

The case, United States v. Montgomery County, No. 26-3025-TDC in the District of Maryland, named the county, its police department and Sheriff Maxwell C. Uy. The department filed it on Aug. 3, 2026, a week after the county council enacted Expedited Bill 23-26 on July 27. The court heard argument on both motions on Oct. 1.

Bill 23-26 amended Chapter 57 of the county code. Section 57-11 bars selling, transferring, possessing or transporting a handgun, rifle, shotgun, ghost gun, undetectable gun, ammunition or major firearm component in or within 100 yards of a place of public assembly. The code defines that term as a park, place of worship, school, library, recreational facility, fairground or conference center, government building open to the public, polling place, courthouse or legislative assembly, including the parking lot and grounds. Exceptions cover a person’s own home, one permitted firearm kept by a business owner or an authorized employee, an unloaded firearm in an enclosed case or locked rack on a vehicle, a firearm locked in a container in a vehicle, and a handgun carried under a state permit in compliance with Section 5-307 of the Maryland Public Safety Article.

The opinion traces the county’s public-assembly restrictions to about 1997. The council narrowed the definition in 2022 after the Supreme Court’s Bruen decision, and narrowed it again in Bill 23-26 after the Supreme Court of Maryland held in Engage Armament LLC v. Montgomery County that the earlier version exceeded the county’s authority under state law. The 2026 bill dropped about five locations from the list, among them hospitals, community health centers, long-term care and childcare facilities, and gatherings for protest, and added the exception for permit holders traveling on public highways within 100 yards of a listed place.

The department argued that the ordinance is presumptively unconstitutional under Bruen and this year’s Wolford v. Lopez, that county officers have a duty to enforce it, and that enforcement would therefore be a pattern or practice of unconstitutional conduct. Chuang rejected that chain of reasoning. Congress wrote Section 12601 in 1994 to address police misconduct, he wrote, with the House report behind it citing the 1991 beating of Rodney King, and the department acknowledged the statute had never been used in the manner it proposed. He pointed to a July 9 ruling by a federal court in California that denied the department a temporary restraining order in a similar Section 12601 suit against a state firearms law and called the approach “at the very least, a novel approach that deviates from the way the statute has historically been enforced.” If Congress had meant to let the executive branch enjoin state and local statutes on constitutional grounds, Chuang wrote, it would have said so explicitly instead of through “the oblique means” of a suit against the officers who enforce them.

Because the complaint failed under the statute, the department could not show a likelihood of success on the merits, and the request for a preliminary injunction fell with it. The court did not decide whether Bill 23-26 violates the Second Amendment. Any appeal goes to the Fourth Circuit, which upheld Maryland’s own sensitive-places law in a decision dated Jan. 20, 2026 that the Supreme Court declined to review on Nov. 16. The opinion says a separate order will follow.

Sources

  1. 1 U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland via CourtListener · Memorandum Opinion, United States v. Montgomery County, No. 26-3025-TDC (D. Md. Nov. 9, 2026) · accessed 2026-11-18
  2. 2 Supreme Court of the United States · Docket No. 25-1324, Novotny v. Moore · accessed 2026-11-18

For brands and PR

Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.

Contact the newsroom

Related Stories