Dispatch / 11.16.26· Law & Courts ·Supreme Court
Supreme Court Denies Maryland Carry Case, Leaving Nine Sensitive-Place Bans Standing as Thomas Questions the Trend
The Nov. 16 denial in Novotny v. Moore leaves the Fourth Circuit's Kipke ruling in place, with bans in transit, parks, bars and seven other categories upheld and one struck, while Justice Thomas calls for a narrower test case and counts 25, 20 and 29 gun-free location types in New Jersey, New York and California.

Key Facts
- The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324, on Nov. 16, 2026.
- The Fourth Circuit's Jan. 20, 2026 Kipke v. Moore ruling upheld nine Maryland carry bans and struck one.
- Justice Thomas agreed with the denial but wrote he has serious doubts about many sweeping restrictions.
- Thomas counted at least 25 gun-free location types in New Jersey, 20 in New York and 29 in California.
- Maryland's brief said the petitioners' security theory was uniformly rejected by the courts of appeals.
On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court denied review in Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324, on its Monday order list, leaving in place a Fourth Circuit decision that upheld Maryland’s bans on carrying firearms in nine categories of places, from mass transit and state parks to bars and public demonstrations. Justice Clarence Thomas filed a four-page statement agreeing with the denial while saying he harbors “serious doubts” that the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation “supports many of these sweeping restrictions.”
The petition, filed May 20 with David H. Thompson of Cooper & Kirk as counsel of record, put one question to the Court: do Maryland’s numerous prohibitions on carrying firearms in places frequented by the general public violate the Second and Fourteenth Amendments. The petitioners are Katherine Novotny, Sue Burke, Esther Rossberg, Maryland Shall Issue, the Second Amendment Foundation, the Firearms Policy Coalition, Susannah Warner Kipke and the Maryland State Rifle and Pistol Association. Their brief argued that the lower courts are eviscerating the right to carry in public, that the circuits are divided on how to judge location restrictions, and that the courts below ignored the role of security in the historical sensitive-places tradition.
Maryland’s brief in opposition, filed August 17 under Attorney General Anthony G. Brown, Solicitor General Julia Doyle and Assistant Attorney General Ryan R. Dietrich as counsel of record, said the petitioners’ comprehensive-security theory “has been uniformly rejected by the courts of appeals” and asked the Court to let the issue percolate given the “harmony among the circuits.” The docket shows the case was docketed May 29, Gun Owners of America filed an amicus brief June 29, the state took two extensions for its response, the petitioners replied September 2, and the petition was distributed for the September 28 conference, rescheduled three times, and then listed for the November 6 and November 13 conferences before the denial.
The decision below is Kipke v. Moore, 165 F.4th 194, decided January 20, 2026, after argument on May 7, 2025. Judge Gregory wrote the opinion, joined by Chief Judge Diaz, and Judge Agee concurred in part and dissented in part. Reviewing Chief District Judge George L. Russell III’s rulings in two consolidated cases, the panel upheld Maryland’s bans in government buildings, on public transportation, on school grounds, in state parks and forests, in museums, in healthcare facilities, and at stadiums, racetracks, amusement parks and casinos. It reversed the district court to uphold two more, the ban within 1,000 feet of a public demonstration and the ban in places that sell alcohol for on-site consumption. The one restriction it struck was the rule barring carry on private property open to the public without the owner’s consent, which the panel held unconstitutional and left enjoined. Judge Agee would have struck the transit, demonstration, park and forest, museum, amusement and alcohol bans.
Thomas wrote that each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition, so the breadth of the challenge “would complicate our review,” and that the Court should take up the scope of state power over sensitive places “in an appropriate and more narrowly focused case.” He recalled that Bruen found early legislatures banned weapons in legislative assemblies, polling places and courthouses, and that the tradition was narrow. States have since stretched the label, he wrote: New Jersey bars firearms in at least 25 locations, including zoos, public libraries, casinos and state-owned beaches, New York has designated 20 sensitive locations, and California lists 29, among them athletic facilities, financial institutions and permitted public gatherings. “The lower courts have largely blessed these ahistorical ventures,” he wrote, citing the Fourth Circuit’s ruling, a now-vacated Third Circuit decision on New Jersey’s law, and the Second and Ninth Circuit decisions on New York and California.
For Maryland carry-permit holders, the nine upheld restrictions remain in force and the private-property default rule remains blocked. The denial comes a week after the Court turned away five other gun cases on its November 9 order list, and the justices hear argument December 2, 2026, in the Illinois and Cook County AR-15 ban cases. AmmoLand described the denial the same day. No further proceeding is scheduled in Novotny, and Thomas named no case as the narrower vehicle he described.
Sources
- 1 Supreme Court of the United States · Order List, November 16, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-16
- 2 Supreme Court of the United States · Statement of Justice Thomas respecting the denial of certiorari, Novotny v. Moore · accessed 2026-11-16
- 3 Supreme Court of the United States · Docket No. 25-1324, Novotny v. Moore · accessed 2026-11-16
- 4 Supreme Court of the United States · Petition for a writ of certiorari, Novotny v. Moore · accessed 2026-11-16
- 5 Supreme Court of the United States · Brief in opposition, Novotny v. Moore · accessed 2026-11-16
- 6 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · Kipke v. Moore, No. 24-1799 (4th Cir. Jan. 20, 2026) · accessed 2026-11-16
- 7 AmmoLand · SCOTUS Leaves Maryland Gun-Free Zones Intact as Justice Thomas Questions Carry Bans · accessed 2026-11-16
For brands and PR
Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.
Contact the newsroomRelated Stories
Law & Courts · Nov 13
AR-15 Ban Challengers Tell Supreme Court the Cook County Case Is Not Moot, Add Two Declarations
The Nov. 11 response says the question presented covers AK-pattern rifles such as Christopher Khaya's Galil, and declarations from Khaya and SAF and FPC member Ed Smolen put AR-15s back in the case before the Dec. 2 argument.
Law & Courts · Nov 11
Justice Department Sues Glendale, California, Over Concealed Carry Costs of Up to $2,000
The suit, filed November 9, 2026, challenges Glendale's $1,078 application fee, psychological exam and social media review under the Second Amendment. It asks a federal court to order the city to invite denied applicants to reapply.
Law & Courts · Nov 9
Cook County Asks Supreme Court to Drop AR-15 Case After Lead Petitioner Quits
The county's Nov. 5 filing says the Dec. 2 case is moot if Cutberto Viramontes withdraws, since the other petitioner wants an AK-pattern Galil, not an AR-15. It concedes Grant v. Higgins would still reach the question.