Dispatch / 11.17.26· Law & Courts ·Virginia
Winchester, Virginia, Paid $37,172.78 Defending a Parking Garage Gun Ban It Then Repealed, FOIA Records Show
Seven checks to the city's defense firm total $35,862.78 and a city attorney invoice adds $1,310. The city says it has no records of the defense firm's hourly rate, and the case was dismissed as moot in May 2026 after the council exempted its garages.

Key Facts
- Winchester's FOIA records show $37,172.78 in legal payments tied to Hyland v. City of Winchester.
- Seven checks to McGavin, Boyce, Bardot, Thorsen & Katz total $35,862.78 from Aug. 1, 2024, to June 12, 2026.
- A Litten & Sipe invoice dated Oct. 5, 2026, bills 5.1 hours for $1,310 at $250 and $275 an hour.
- The city's portal lists the Oct. 30, 2026, request for the defense firm's rate and invoices as No Responsive Records.
- The council exempted public parking garages on May 12, 2026, and the court dismissed the case as moot on May 26.
Winchester, Virginia, paid $37,172.78 to two law firms over the lawsuit against its parking garage gun ban, records the city released under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act show. The records, a payment report and a city attorney invoice, were posted on Nov. 17 by AmmoLand, whose contributor John Crump reported them, and the city’s records portal lists a follow-up request for the defense firm’s hourly rate and invoices as having no responsive records.
The payment report lists seven checks to McGavin, Boyce, Bardot, Thorsen & Katz, P.C., under claim 02-23-56091-1-PO, with Patrick Hyland as the claimant and a loss date of Jan. 12, 2024. Each is marked “Defense Attorney” under the City Attorney department. The checks total $35,862.78 and cover billing periods from Jan. 12, 2024, through June 3, 2026.
| Check date | Billing period | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Aug. 1, 2024 | Jan. 12 to July 27, 2024 | $10,630.32 |
| Nov. 12, 2024 | July 27 to Nov. 11, 2024 | $6,855.70 |
| Dec. 11, 2024 | Nov. 25 to Dec. 4, 2024 | $2,986.59 |
| March 21, 2025 | Feb. 10 to March 18, 2025 | $1,481.87 |
| Sept. 18, 2025 | July 8 to Sept. 15, 2025 | $2,679.00 |
| Oct. 28, 2025 | Oct. 6 to Oct. 25, 2025 | $1,281.50 |
| June 12, 2026 | Oct. 27, 2025, to June 3, 2026 | $9,947.80 |
The second document is invoice HY 08104 from Litten & Sipe, L.L.P., of Harrisonburg, dated Oct. 5, 2026, and addressed to City Manager John Piper. It bills 5.1 hours on the Hyland matter for $1,310, at $250 an hour in 2024 and 2025 and $275 an hour in 2026, and is marked paid. Several of its entries also cover the related Stickley and VCDL lawsuits and the city’s handling of 2024 FOIA requests for its legal bills, so the $37,172.78 total is the sum of both documents and not a figure the city has stated for the Hyland case alone.
A supplemental FOIA request dated Oct. 30, 2026, asked for every invoice paid to or requested by the defense firm, its detailed time entries and documentation of its hourly rate. The portal entry for that request, reference W008638-103026, reads “No Responsive Records,” and the city’s Nov. 5 reply, as AmmoLand quotes it, said the city “has reviewed its files and has determined there are no additional responsive documents to your request.”
The invoice entries sketch the case. Litten & Sipe billed emails about a “Court Order in Hyland” on June 4, 2024, the “Hyland motion for Summary Judgment and City’s Response” on July 23, 2025, the “Hyland lawsuit and amendment to gun ban ordinance” on April 18, 2026, and the “Hyland dismissal” on May 15, 2026. In AmmoLand’s account of the Winchester Circuit Court docket, an agreed order of June 11, 2024, barred enforcement of the ban in the garages named in the complaint, the City Council amended the ordinance on May 12, 2026, to exempt city-owned parking structures, garages and decks open to the public, and the court dismissed the case as moot and without prejudice on May 26, 2026, so no judge ruled on the ban. The Gun Owners Foundation and the Virginia Citizens Defense League backed the suit.
Winchester’s ordinance rests on House Bill 421 of 2020, Chapter 1205, effective July 1, 2020, which authorizes any Virginia locality to prohibit by ordinance the possession or carrying of firearms, ammunition and components in buildings it owns or uses for governmental purposes, in its public parks, in recreation centers and at permitted events. The City Council first adopted its ban on Feb. 9, 2021, by a 7-2 vote and narrowed it in November 2022, again 7-2, after an earlier suit, keeping the ban on city buildings, in AmmoLand’s account. The May 2026 garage exemption is the second time the city has pulled back the ordinance under litigation, and the city has not said why it amended it.
Sources
- 1 City of Winchester, via AmmoLand · Hyland v. City of Winchester payment report (VRSA claim 02-23-56091-1-PO) · accessed 2026-11-17
- 2 City of Winchester, via AmmoLand · Litten & Sipe invoice HY 08104, Hyland Matter · accessed 2026-11-17
- 3 AmmoLand · Supplemental Virginia FOIA request, Hyland v. City of Winchester legal expenditures · accessed 2026-11-17
- 4 City of Winchester, via AmmoLand · Winchester FOIA portal entry W008638-103026, No Responsive Records · accessed 2026-11-17
- 5 Virginia Legislative Information System · HB 421 (2020) Firearms, ammunition, etc.; control by localities · accessed 2026-11-17
- 6 AmmoLand · Winchester Backed Down on Gun Ban After $37,000 in Legal Payments, FOIA Records Reveal · accessed 2026-11-17
For brands and PR
Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.
Contact the newsroomRelated Stories
Law & Courts · Nov 16
Supreme Court Denies Maryland Carry Case, Leaving Nine Sensitive-Place Bans Standing as Thomas Questions the Trend
The Nov. 16 denial in Novotny v. Moore leaves the Fourth Circuit's Kipke ruling in place, with bans in transit, parks, bars and seven other categories upheld and one struck, while Justice Thomas calls for a narrower test case and counts 25, 20 and 29 gun-free location types in New Jersey, New York and California.
Law & Courts · Nov 13
Florida Attorney General Says the State's 2018 Bump Stock Ban Violates the Second Amendment and Won't Defend Convictions
James Uthmeier's Nov. 13 opinion finds no historical tradition for section 790.222's third-degree felony, cites Cargill and an ATF estimate of more than 500,000 bump stocks in circulation, and says executive branch officials cannot lawfully enforce it, though only the Legislature or a court can repeal it.
Law & Courts · Nov 13
First Circuit Revives New Hampshire Man's Challenge to Federal Gun Ban Over Two DUI Convictions
The Nov. 13 opinion in Marshall v. Blanche says the court's 2011 Torres-Rosario precedent no longer controls after Levasseur, vacates the dismissal and sends the case back for a Bruen analysis of the background check denial, while holding Marshall lacks standing to attack the possession ban itself.