AmmoSight

Dispatch / 11.19.26· Law & Courts

ATF Destroyed an Oklahoma Pastor's 39 Forfeited Guns on June 12, 83 Days Before His Sept. 3 Pardon, Director Says

ATF Director Robert Cekada gave Russell Fincher a Report of Destruction dating the loss of his 39 firearms to June 12, 2026, and said no video exists. The Pardon Attorney's record lists Fincher's two-year probation sentence among 23 pardons signed Sept. 3.

By Published
Credit: Photo: ajay_suresh, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

Key Facts

  • ATF's Report of Destruction dates the loss of Fincher's 39 forfeited guns to June 12, 2026, 83 days before his pardon.
  • The Pardon Attorney lists Fincher's Nov. 19, 2024 sentence as two years' probation for selling ammunition to a prohibited person.
  • Agents seized more than 50 personal firearms on June 15, 2023, and the plea let Fincher keep 13 while forfeiting 39.
  • Cekada said no cameras cover the National Destruction Branch's process, after first telling Fincher the destruction was videotaped.
  • The FBI had denied gun purchases by Fincher and fellow pardon recipient Patrick Tate Adamiak as of Oct. 23.

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives destroyed the 39 firearms it kept from Russell Fincher on June 12, 2026, 83 days before President Donald Trump pardoned the Oklahoma pastor and former gun dealer on Sept. 3, ATF Director Robert Cekada told the Second Amendment Foundation’s Investigative Journalism Project in a report published Nov. 19. Cekada supplied several pages of an agency “Report of Destruction” listing the guns, and he said the agency’s National Destruction Branch destroyed them at a West Virginia facility with no video record of the process.

Fincher, a Baptist minister and high school teacher, sold guns and ammunition from a shed behind his home in Tuskahoma, Oklahoma, as Triple G Firearms LLC until ATF agents raided the house on June 15, 2023, the project’s May 30, 2024 account of the case says. Agents seized more than 50 of his personal firearms, among them a Wilson Combat pistol, five Glocks and a pre-ban Polytech AK, and he surrendered his federal firearms license that day. A federal grand jury indicted him that November on three counts: dealing firearms without a license, selling ammunition to a prohibited person and making a false entry in dealer records. He signed a plea agreement on May 17, 2024, admitting that on May 5, 2023 he sold 60 rounds of .40 S&W ammunition to a buyer he had reason to believe was a felon, and he agreed not to contest the forfeiture of 39 firearms. Fincher kept 13 guns, which he said he later sold to pay bills during a year without work.

The Office of the Pardon Attorney’s clemency record lists Fincher under the Sept. 3, 2026 warrant as sentenced in the Eastern District of Oklahoma to two years’ probation on Nov. 19, 2024 for selling ammunition to a prohibited person. His was one of 23 pardons and six commutations signed that day, a group that also included Patrick Tate Adamiak, a former Navy sailor serving 240 months in the Eastern District of Virginia on unregistered firearm, machine gun and destructive device counts, Shane Cox and Jeremy Kettler, the Kansas defendants from the 2017 Kansas Second Amendment Protection Act prosecution, and George Peterson, a Louisiana man serving 24 months for possessing an unregistered silencer.

Fincher said Cekada first told him, in a phone call that ran more than an hour, that the guns were destroyed in August and that the destruction had been videotaped. The project filed a Freedom of Information Act request on Nov. 17 for the video. Cekada then said by text that he may have been mistaken and that the cameras he saw were installed for security, and after reading the National Destruction Branch’s policy he wrote: “Ok confirmed there are no cameras for the destruction process just overall security.” By his account the branch, part of ATF’s Asset Forfeiture Division, destroys firearms for every Justice Department law enforcement component. Its staff document receipt of the guns from FedEx, verify make, model and serial number, execute a report of destruction once the firearms are gone and update the department’s Consolidated Asset Tracking System. The pages Cekada supplied put the destruction date at June 12, 2026, two months earlier than the August date he first gave Fincher.

Fincher is not satisfied. “Prove to me, show me the evidence they were destroyed, show me the video,” he said, and he told the project that agents had admired the higher-end guns during the raid. “They got all the higher end guns,” he said of the forfeiture split, adding that it took him three years to save for the Wilson Combat. Cekada said Fincher “has a right to complain about what he went through.”

The pardon has not yet cleared Fincher at the gun counter. In an Oct. 23 piece the project said the FBI had denied Form 4473 purchases by both Fincher, who tried to buy a Smith & Wesson Victory handgun through a local dealer, and Adamiak, who was also denied by the Pennsylvania State Police instant check and mailed a paper appeal. “We don’t block anybody. The 4473 goes to the FBI,” Cekada said then.

Shooting News Weekly republished the report on Nov. 19. ATF has not posted the Report of Destruction or a statement on the case, and the Pardon Attorney’s page carries an Oct. 20, 2026 update date. The project’s FOIA request, filed Nov. 17, is the next document in the case, and a destruction date 83 days before the pardon is now the agency’s own position on where the 39 guns went.

Sources

  1. 1 Second Amendment Foundation Investigative Journalism Project · ATF: Pastor Russell Fincher's guns were all destroyed before his Presidential pardon · accessed 2026-11-19
  2. 2 U.S. Department of Justice, Office of the Pardon Attorney · Clemency Grants by President Donald J. Trump (2025-Present) · accessed 2026-11-19
  3. 3 Second Amendment Foundation Investigative Journalism Project · Presidential pardon recipients still barred from buying guns · accessed 2026-11-19
  4. 4 The Gun Writer (Lee Williams) · Oklahoma gun dealer raided by ATF takes plea, but serious questions remain · accessed 2026-11-19
  5. 5 Shooting News Weekly · He Got a Presidential Pardon, But Not Before All of His Guns Were Destroyed by ATF · accessed 2026-11-19

For brands and PR

Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.

Contact the newsroom

Related Stories