AmmoSight

Dispatch / 11.20.26· Law & Courts ·Iowa

Sig Sauer Will Seek Post-Trial Relief and Appeal After New York Jury Verdict in Troy Officer's P320 Case

A Northern District of New York jury found for Troy officer Michael Colwell, whose P320 fired in its holster on June 2, 2021. The case survived a 2024 summary judgment loss through the Second Circuit, and Judge D'Agostino's Nov. 12 order let in other-incident videos while barring expert causation testimony.

By Published
Credit: Photo: Daniel Case, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Key Facts

  • Sig Sauer said Nov. 20, 2026, it will seek post-trial relief and appeal the Colwell v. Sig Sauer verdict, No. 1:21-cv-1200.
  • Troy officer Michael Colwell's holstered P320 fired during a June 2, 2021, room-clearing drill, the complaint says.
  • Chief Judge Sannes granted Sig Sauer summary judgment on Sept. 17, 2024, before the Second Circuit's Colwell II decision.
  • Judge D'Agostino's Nov. 12, 2026, order admitted other P320 discharge videos, muted except at the shot.
  • The statement counts 26 P320 dismissals or defense verdicts and a 113,479-firearm military inspection.
  • The verdict form and judgment are not among the RECAP documents, and the statement gives no amount.

Sig Sauer said on Nov. 20, 2026, that it will file a motion for post-trial relief and then appeal a federal jury’s verdict for Troy, New York, police officer Michael Colwell, whose P320 fired inside its holster during a June 2, 2021, training drill. In a statement from Newington, New Hampshire, the company said it “strongly disagree[s] with the verdict.” The case is Colwell v. Sig Sauer, Inc., No. 1:21-cv-1200, tried before U.S. District Judge Mae A. D’Agostino in the Northern District of New York. The docket available through RECAP runs through pretrial rulings dated Nov. 12 and entries dated Nov. 14 and 15, and the verdict form and judgment are not among the public documents. The statement gives neither the verdict date nor the amount.

Kristen Dennison, counsel for Sig Sauer, said the parties agreed the discharge occurred when the trigger was pulled and that “there was no credible evidence presented that anything other than Plaintiff’s finger pulled the trigger.” She said statements from Colwell himself show he was holstering the pistol, and that “any claim that a tabbed trigger would have prevented this incident was purely speculative.” The company said the jury was never shown the firearm and that both of the plaintiff’s experts examined a pistol with the wrong serial number. It will ask the court to enter judgment in its favor and, if denied, “appeal the decision on multiple grounds.” The statement counts 26 case dismissals or defense verdicts in P320 cases and cites the U.S. military’s inspection of 113,479 firearms before affirming the M17 and M18 as “safe and reliable.”

The complaint, filed Nov. 2, 2021, says Colwell was running a room-clearing drill with his service-issued P320 and live ammunition. After the third room he holstered the pistol on his right hip and reached across his body for a simulated taser, and the P320 fired from inside the holster. The bullet entered his upper right thigh, passed through the quadriceps and exited above the knee. The complaint pleaded seven counts for Colwell and his wife. By trial the case had narrowed to strict product liability, negligence and breach of the implied warranty of merchantability. Julia Colwell was dismissed as a plaintiff on Oct. 20, 2026, and the plaintiff withdrew the express warranty, emotional distress and loss of consortium counts.

Data
Date Event in Colwell v. Sig Sauer
June 2, 2021 P320 fires in its holster during Troy police training
Nov. 2, 2021 Complaint filed in the Northern District of New York
Sept. 17, 2024 Chief Judge Sannes excludes both causation experts, grants summary judgment on Counts I and II
2026 Second Circuit decides Colwell II, 177 F.4th 382, and the case returns for trial
Nov. 12, 2026 Judge D’Agostino rules on the pretrial motions
Nov. 20, 2026 Sig Sauer says it will seek post-trial relief and appeal

The case had been lost once. On Sept. 17, 2024, Chief Judge Brenda K. Sannes excluded the causation opinions of gunsmith James Tertin and human factors engineer William Vigilante and granted Sig Sauer summary judgment on the first two counts, noting that the P320 at issue had no manual thumb safety or tabbed trigger safety. The Second Circuit’s 2026 decision, cited in the trial court’s Nov. 12 order as Colwell II, left the experts’ design-defect opinions standing. Judge D’Agostino quoted the appeals court’s observation that the experts “reliably opined that the P320’s trigger is more likely to effect an inadvertent discharge than a tabbed trigger based on the available surface area for actuation,” and its footnote that the P320 “cannot discharge without its trigger being depressed.”

Judge D’Agostino’s Nov. 12 order set the trial’s evidentiary lines. She let the jury hear that the Troy Police Department kept using the P320 without complaints. The order admitted videos and depositions of other P320 discharges under the four-part similarity test used by Judge Saris in two District of Massachusetts cases, Desrosiers and Catatao, requiring a model with the same light, short trigger and no external safety, an unintended trigger actuation, no flush finger contact with the trigger face and no drop or abusive handling, with the videos muted except at the moment of discharge. Colwell’s bid to keep out Sig Sauer’s drop and abuse testing evidence was denied. The judge barred any evidence inconsistent with the Second Circuit’s statement that the P320 cannot fire without its trigger being depressed, and ruled that Colwell’s experts “may not testify as to what caused Plaintiff’s P320 to discharge,” while Colwell agreed not to argue the pistol can fire without the trigger being fully actuated. Sig Sauer’s late challenge to Vigilante’s qualifications was refused as well, the court finding no good cause for a motion brought “over three years” after it could have been.

Other P320 suits where similar-incident evidence came in are named in the order: Cole in Maine, Desrosiers and Catatao in Massachusetts and Guay in New Hampshire. The company’s next filing is the post-trial motion for judgment it announced Nov. 20, 2026, and the appeal it promised if that motion fails. The docket’s latest public entries are dated Nov. 14 and 15, 2026, and the case remains open before Judge D’Agostino in Albany.

Sources

  1. 1 Sig Sauer · SIG SAUER Intends to Pursue Post-Verdict Relief and Appeal in New York Unintended Discharge Case · accessed 2026-11-20
  2. 2 U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York, via RECAP · Memorandum-Decision and Order on motions in limine, Colwell v. Sig Sauer, Inc., No. 1:21-cv-1200 (N.D.N.Y. Nov. 12, 2026), Dkt. 209 · accessed 2026-11-20
  3. 3 U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York, via RECAP · Decision and Order, Colwell v. Sig Sauer, Inc., No. 1:21-cv-1200 (N.D.N.Y. Sept. 17, 2024), Dkt. 75 · accessed 2026-11-20
  4. 4 U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York, via RECAP · Complaint, Colwell v. Sig Sauer, Inc., No. 1:21-cv-1200 (N.D.N.Y. Nov. 2, 2021), Dkt. 1 · accessed 2026-11-20

For brands and PR

Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.

Contact the newsroom

Related Stories