AmmoSight

Dispatch / 11.20.26· Law & Courts ·Iowa

Synagogue Asks Fourth Circuit to Let Armed Permit Holders Walk to Sabbath Services in Montgomery County's 100-Yard Zones

Silver Spring Jewish Center and Rabbi J. Menashe Shapiro moved on Nov. 10 for an injunction pending appeal after a district judge left the county's 100-yard buffers in force. Montgomery County answered on Nov. 17 that there is no emergency, and the motion was fully briefed on Nov. 18.

By Published
Credit: Photo: Acroterion, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Key Facts

  • Silver Spring Jewish Center and Rabbi Menashe Shapiro moved for an injunction pending appeal in the Fourth Circuit on Nov. 10, 2026.
  • The rabbi's only walking route to the synagogue passes within 100 yards of four schools, two parks and three houses of worship.
  • Judge Deborah Chasanow enjoined the place-of-worship ban for the plaintiffs on Sept. 10 but left the 100-yard buffers in force.
  • Montgomery County opposed the motion on Nov. 17, calling the plaintiffs' challenge facial and saying there is no emergency.
  • The appeal is on informal briefing with the opening brief due Dec. 4, 2026, and the motion awaits a ruling.

Silver Spring Jewish Center and Rabbi Menashe Shapiro asked the Fourth Circuit on Nov. 10, 2026 to bar Montgomery County, Maryland, from enforcing its 100-yard firearm buffer against the rabbi and the synagogue’s permit-holding members while they walk between their homes and the synagogue on the Sabbath and Jewish holidays. Their motion for an injunction pending appeal, docketed as No. 26-2623, says the only path between the rabbi’s home and the Orthodox synagogue passes within 100 yards of four schools, two parks and three other houses of worship, each a place of public assembly under the county code. Montgomery County opposed the motion on Nov. 17, the plaintiffs replied on Nov. 18, and the motion now awaits a ruling.

The ordinance at issue is Expedited Bill 23-26, enacted July 27, 2026, which bars a person from selling, transferring, possessing or transporting a handgun, rifle or shotgun, or ammunition or a major component for those firearms, in or within 100 yards of a place of public assembly. Section 57-1 of the county code defines that term to include any park, place of worship, school, library, government building or polling place and all property associated with the place. Section 57-11(b)(6) exempts a firearm carried in a motor vehicle if it is locked in a container or is a handgun carried by a holder of a Maryland wear-and-carry permit. In the county’s words, it “drew its line at the vehicle.”

U.S. District Judge Deborah K. Chasanow found on Sept. 10 that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their Second Amendment and Free Exercise challenges to the ban inside places of worship and enjoined the county from enforcing Sections 57-1 and 57-11(a)(1) against them “in THEIR respective places of worship.” Her 72-page opinion stopped there. It treated the Second Amendment challenge to the buffers as a facial one, found a buffer around a school presumptively constitutional, and said of the rabbi’s own claim that “he is like any other licensed gun carrier.” The opinion also records the county’s commitments while the case is pending: the state’s attorney will defer criminal prosecutions under Sections 57-10 and 57-11, county police will not issue criminal citations under them, and officers could still issue civil citations. Chasanow denied the plaintiffs’ motion to amend the judgment or for an injunction pending appeal on Oct. 27, finding that they did “not now seek relief distinct from what the court previously evaluated.”

The plaintiffs, represented by the New Civil Liberties Alliance and the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty with the rabbi appearing for himself, argue that the district court erred by treating their buffer challenge as facial after writing in September that they “would only need to succeed on an as-applied challenge.” They say the county offered no historical evidence for the 100-yard rule until the reconsideration stage, and that the vehicle exemption lets the same permit holders carry the same handguns along the same streets as long as they drive, which in their view makes the rule not generally applicable under the Supreme Court’s Fulton decision. The motion describes the synagogue’s armed volunteer security team, all of whose members are licensed under Maryland law to carry, and cites an October 2024 attack on a visibly Jewish member just outside the building and a June 2026 attempt by an unknown person to get inside. Because the synagogue is itself a place of worship, the motion says, the ban keeps members from even approaching the building while armed.

Part of the ground is already conceded. In its Oct. 8 opposition to reconsideration in the district court, the county wrote that, without waiving its arguments, it does “not oppose Plaintiffs’ request for preliminary injunctive relief as to the Buffer Zone specifically surrounding SSJC.” The motion says the Oct. 27 ruling did not address that concession.

In the Fourth Circuit, the county’s 28-page opposition opens with the line “There is no emergency.” It argues that the plaintiffs conceded at the Sept. 3 hearing that “these are facial challenges” to the provisions, that the 100-yard restriction “has been County law since 2022,” and that criminal prosecutions are deferred while the case proceeds. The plaintiffs have submitted no evidence that the rabbi or any member “actually has been threatened with a civil fine,” the county says, and a potential “once per week” exposure to a civil fine “does not rise to the level of” actual and imminent irreparable injury. On the vehicle exemption, the county writes that a firearm locked in a container in a car “cannot readily be drawn or used at the sensitive place, unlike a pedestrian’s holstered handgun.”

The 910-word reply answers that the county “completely ignore[s]” the burden on the security team, whose members “cannot even transport a firearm to the front door,” and that the county “does not attempt to argue that the buffer-zone prohibition meets strict scrutiny.” The requested injunction would reach Montgomery County Code Section 57-11(a)(1) only as it bars the rabbi and permit-holding members from possessing or transporting a handgun on the walk between their homes and the synagogue on the Sabbath and Jewish holidays.

On Nov. 10 the clerk’s office asked the county to respond to the motion by Nov. 17. The court placed the appeal on an informal briefing schedule with the opening brief due Dec. 4, 2026, and on Nov. 12 it denied the plaintiffs’ request for a formal briefing schedule while granting them leave to file a brief in any format.

The same ordinance survived a separate federal attack this month. U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang dismissed the Justice Department’s pattern-or-practice suit against the county on Nov. 9 without deciding whether Bill 23-26 violates the Second Amendment, and no notice of appeal appeared on that docket as of Nov. 20.

Sources

  1. 1 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (RECAP) · Appellants' motion for injunction pending appeal, No. 26-2623, Nov. 10, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  2. 2 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (RECAP) · Defendant-Appellee's opposition to motion for injunction pending appeal, Nov. 17, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  3. 3 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (RECAP) · Plaintiffs-Appellants' reply in support of motion for injunction pending appeal, Nov. 18, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  4. 4 U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (RECAP) · Memorandum opinion, Silver Spring Jewish Center v. Montgomery County, D. Md., Sept. 10, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  5. 5 U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (RECAP) · Order granting preliminary injunction in part, D. Md., Sept. 10, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  6. 6 U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (RECAP) · Order denying motion to amend judgment or for injunction pending appeal, D. Md., Oct. 27, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  7. 7 U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (RECAP) · Defendants' opposition to motion to amend judgment or for injunction pending appeal, D. Md., Oct. 8, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  8. 8 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (RECAP) · Clerk's response-requested notice, Nov. 10, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  9. 9 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (RECAP) · Order denying formal briefing schedule, Nov. 12, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  10. 10 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (RECAP) · Informal briefing order, Nov. 10, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20
  11. 11 U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (RECAP) · Memorandum opinion, United States v. Montgomery County, D. Md., Nov. 9, 2026 · accessed 2026-11-20

For brands and PR

Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.

Contact the newsroom

Related Stories