Dispatch / 11.19.26· Law & Courts
Fifth Circuit Says the Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales and Sends a Louisiana Unlicensed-Dealing Conviction Back, 2-1
A per curiam panel vacated the denial of Jeremiah Deare's motion to dismiss a § 922(a)(1) indictment on Nov. 19, 2026, after the government conceded the amendment reaches commercial sales. Judge Oldham told the trial court to ignore the circuit's Peterson suppressor decision, and Judge Haynes dissented.

Key Facts
- The Fifth Circuit vacated the order denying Jeremiah Deare's motion to dismiss on Nov. 19, 2026, and remanded, 2-1.
- Deare was convicted on all counts of a § 922(a)(1) unlicensed-dealing conspiracy and false-statement indictment and sentenced to 97 months.
- The government conceded at oral argument that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms.
- Judge Oldham, joined by Judge Ho, called the 2025 Peterson suppressor decision gravely mistaken and told the district court to ignore it.
- Judge Haynes dissented, saying Deare never showed the dealer rules are abusive and the conviction should be affirmed.
- The remand follows the Sept. 18, 2026 Elite Precision ruling that struck down the interstate handgun sales ban in § 922.
The Fifth Circuit held on Nov. 19, 2026 that the Second Amendment’s plain text covers the sale of firearms and sent a Louisiana man’s unlicensed-dealing case back to the trial court, 2-1. The per curiam opinion in United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, vacates the order that denied Jeremiah Micah Deare’s motion to dismiss his indictment and remands for further proceedings. Judge Andrew Oldham, joined by Judge James Ho, wrote separately to tell the district court to ignore the circuit’s own 2025 Peterson decision on the National Firearms Act. Judge Catharina Haynes dissented.
Deare was indicted in the Western District of Louisiana, No. 6:21-CR-212-1, for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license under 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1) and for making false statements with respect to the records of licensed dealers. He moved to dismiss, arguing that the licensing requirement and the record-keeping rules tied to it violate the Second Amendment. The district court denied the motion in 2023, holding that federal licensing and record-keeping requirements are not implicated by the Second Amendment because they do not affect an individual’s right to keep or bear arms, and that even if they were, they fit the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. A jury convicted Deare on all counts and the court sentenced him to 97 months in prison.
The panel’s two-page opinion disposes of the first question only. “The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms,” the court wrote, quoting its January 2025 decision in Reese v. ATF, 127 F.4th 583, that the right to keep and bear arms “surely implies the right to purchase them.” At oral argument the government conceded that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms. The court therefore vacated the denial and remanded without reaching the second step of the Bruen test, whether the licensing scheme is consistent with historical tradition. A footnote lists Deare’s three other arguments, that the statute is unconstitutionally vague and was read through an agency interpretation, that the sentence is substantively unreasonable and that the evidence was insufficient, which the panel left for the district court’s further proceedings along with the conviction and the 97-month sentence.
Judge Oldham’s concurrence in the judgment, which Judge Ho joined, says restricting the sale of firearms obviously infringes the right to keep and bear arms in two ways, because a seller’s right to keep a gun includes the right to dispose of it and because the right to keep an item always includes the right to acquire it. He then gives the district court instructions for remand. It should be guided by Elite Precision Customs LLC v. ATF, 191 F.4th 733, the Fifth Circuit’s Sept. 18, 2026 decision that struck down the three provisions of § 922, subsections (a)(3), (a)(5) and (b)(3), that together bar direct interstate handgun sales. Judge Jerry Smith wrote that opinion for a panel with Judge Kurt Engelhardt, reversing a Northern District of Texas dismissal and rendering judgment for Elite Precision Customs, two individual buyers and the Firearms Policy Coalition, and Judge Haynes dissented there too.
The district court should not rely on United States v. Peterson, 161 F.4th 331, Judge Oldham wrote. In a supplemental brief the Justice Department argued that Peterson, which upheld a prosecution for possessing an unregistered suppressor, makes § 922(a) presumptively constitutional because Peterson read footnote nine of Bruen to presume that shall-issue licensing regimes are valid. Judge Oldham called Peterson gravely mistaken, said it should be overruled at the earliest opportunity, and said that in any event it concerns the National Firearms Act’s registration system and has nothing to do with the Gun Control Act’s limits on sales. Applying it as the government urged, he wrote, would take a footnote about carry licenses, extend it to firearm registration and then to firearm sales, moving “from football to baseball to ballroom dance.” He also cited Silencer Shop Foundation v. ATF, an Aug. 5, 2026 Northern District of Texas decision, on how the registry restricts transfers of registered items.
Judge Ho’s separate concurrence answers the dissent’s textual point that sellers appear nowhere in the Second Amendment. By that logic, he wrote, booksellers would fall outside a First Amendment that names no sellers, “but that can’t be right.” He cited his 2018 dissent from the denial of rehearing in Mance v. Sessions, which had upheld the interstate handgun sales ban that Elite Precision has now struck down.
Judge Haynes wrote that she does not think the sellers of guns are covered by an amendment that speaks only of the people’s right to keep and bear arms, but that she accepts the panel majority’s view given the circuit’s prior cases and the government’s concession. Even so, she saw nothing showing that the rules for sellers are abusive and said Deare did not properly challenge them on that ground, so she would simply affirm the conviction.
The decision is the Fifth Circuit’s third Second Amendment ruling against a federal firearms-commerce statute in 2026, after the Oct. 21 Knife Rights v. Blanche decision on the Federal Switchblade Act’s interstate ban and the Sept. 18 Elite Precision decision. It reaches a federal firearms license requirement for the first time in a criminal appeal. On remand the Western District of Louisiana must decide whether the § 922(a)(1) licensing requirement and the dealer record-keeping rules are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation, the Bruen second step the panel left open, and the government may seek rehearing en banc within 45 days of the Nov. 19 judgment under the federal appellate rules for cases in which the United States is a party.
Sources
- 1 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241 (5th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026) · accessed 2026-11-20
- 2 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, via CourtListener · Elite Precision Customs L.L.C. v. ATF, No. 25-11206 (5th Cir. Sept. 18, 2026) · accessed 2026-11-20
For brands and PR
Covering your product? Send launch details, press images and review samples to the newsroom. Samples do not guarantee coverage or a positive review.
Contact the newsroomRelated Stories
Law & Courts · Nov 19
ATF-Led Indianapolis Operation Charges 35 Defendants, Seizes 161 Guns and 173 Machine Gun Conversion Devices in Six Weeks
Operation Circle City Shield, run Oct. 5 to Nov. 17, 2026 by the ATF Columbus Field Division with 17 partner agencies, produced 25 indictments and two complaints. Sixteen defendants face felon-in-possession counts and three face machine gun charges.
Law & Courts · Nov 19
New Mexico Agrees to a Statewide Injunction Against Its 7-Day Gun Waiting Period, Pending Only a Tenth Circuit Reversal in Ortega
Attorney General Raúl Torrez and the NSSF-led plaintiffs filed a joint motion Nov. 18, 2026 for a stipulated injunction against House Bill 129 in NSSF v. Torrez. Magistrate Judge Jerry H. Ritter has not yet signed it, and the state's answer is due Dec. 17.
Law & Courts · Nov 19
Gun Theft Prevention Act Would Hire 650 ATF Inspectors, Mandate Annual Inspections at 25 Traces and Pull Stolen Guns From PLCAA
Rep. Joe Morelle and Sen. Lisa Blunt Rochester introduced the 13-section bill Nov. 19, 2026. The text sets a $2,500 to $20,000 penalty ladder, 30-day post-theft inspections and repeals the Tiahrt trace-data and physical-inventory riders.